Problem with subtitle position & PGS subtitle

[Perlnx]

Hello,
I use Infuse Pro 5.5.5 with Apple TV 4K. I have problem with subtitle that place incorrect position.
The movie are MKV 1080p. There are 4 type of subtitle.

• Vobsub_Normal
• Vobsub_Low (Place in bottom of video)
• PGS_Normal
• PGS_Low (Place in bottom of video)

Subtitle language : Thai
I compare problem with Kodi for better understanding.

Infuse : Vobsub_Normal
It’s appear near the middle of screen

Kodi : Vobsub_Normal
It’s place correct position. Moreover the subtitle in Infuse are display in the incorrect aspect ratio (It’s flat)

---

Infuse : Vobsub_Low
Its appear above the letterbox

Kodi : Vobsub_Low
Its appear below the letterbox, which is correct position.

---

Infuse : PGS_Normal
Correct position, a bit lower than Kodi

Kodi : PGS_Normal

---

Infuse : PGS_Low
Too low, close to TV edge.

Kodi : PGS_Low
It’s the best position to watch.

---

Moreover, The app doesn’t hide subtitle that mark as “disable”, every subtitle are able to choose in playback.

When watching in MPC.

Watching with Infuse.

Is it anyway to fix this ?

[Perlnx]

I try to do more test. Seem like It may relate to something with movie & screen resolution
My ATV running in 4K and most movie are 1080p.

The problem are more appear when use PGS subtitle.

Example
The Matrix (1080p) with PGS_Normal = Subtitle too large and not stay in the middle.

Jason Bourne (1080p) with PGS_Low = A bit lower but acceptable.

Jason Bourne (4K) with PGS_Low = Very small and stay in the middle left of screen.

These problem not occur when playing with Kodi.

[opticalfiber]

James is aware of the issue and is looking into it: Incorrect subtitle position for 4K media

[Perlnx]

Thanks for info.
What about 1080p? I also have problem with that resolution as well.

[james]

5.6 is now available for iOS and Apple TV.

Infuse 5.6 - A fresh new look + HDR

[Perlnx]

Thank you for info. Here’s test result.

4K Movie

• Both Vobsub & PGS display in the same position. If can adjust a bit lower it will gonna be perfect.

1080p Movie

• Vobsub still display near the middle of screen
• PGS also display in the same position as Vobsub (In version 5.5, PGS place in the good position but a bit too low)
• Both Vobsub & PGS look flat (This not occur in 4K movie)

Looking forward for fix

[james]

Would you be able to send in a sample or two of the affected files we could review here?

Dropbox - Submit files

[Perlnx]

I’ve uploaded 2 weeks ago, please check these file

Uploaded, Trim version of 4 movies that I show in the forum.

Filename :
Gravity [2013] - Trim.mkv
The Matrix Reloaded [2003] - Trim.mkv
Jason Bourne [2016] - Trim.mkv
Jason Bourne [2016] 4K - Trim.mkv

All movie default with “Vobsub_Low” and disable flag to hide 480, 720 & yellow subtitle.

[james]

Thanks. Must have missed that.

Will take a look.

[james]

A number of improvements have been added in today’s 5.6.2 update.

Give it a try and let us know how it goes.

[Perlnx]

Thank you, I will test and let you know the result soon.

[Perlnx]

Still not work as aspect. let me explain problem for you.
We have 2 problem with vobsub & pgs subtitle

1. Position
2. Aspect ratio

Position :
I have compared between 3 application, please check.

Subtitle should stay in the position like Kodi. Vobsub_Normal should stay in the bottom of video and Vobsub_Low should stay under movie (in the letterbox) which are correct position and not interfere when viewing but when use Vobsub_Normal via Infuse. It nearly middle of screen.

Aspect Ratio :
Please check the screenshot

I have extract Vobsub_Normal with vobsub resync and see what is correct size of subtitle. Infuse & MPC show incorrect aspect ratio because the height of subtitle look shorter. It hard to reading.

[Perlnx]

Just re-check. I thing last time my Infuse are not updated yet.
Now with 5.6.2 every subtitle are perfect. Correct subtitle position & aspect ratio.

Thank you to fix this problem. I love it !

[james]

Great to hear!