New AppleTV2 Restore Loop?

This is the picture I get every time I plug in the Apple TV 2 I just bought from GainSaver. Does anyone have any suggestions as to what to do? TinyUmbrella keeps kicking it out of Restore but it goes right back in and “Fix Recovery” is greyed out. RecBoot kicks it out of recovery but then it goes right back in. When I plug it into my TV it is not recognized by the TV and just stays black. Through some restores I have seen the Apple logo and the “connect to iTunes” icon but never have gotten to the Language Select. What can I do?[[wysiwyg_imageupload:152:]]

What iOS version are you trying to restore? Or are you simply clicking the Restore button?

I am trying to restore to normal 4.4.4. I’ve done it by clicking it and option-clicking it.