Is it normal that Infuse mostly suggests shows and movies I have already watched or marked as watched?

I would assume that the suggestions on the top part of the Infuse home screen would suggest Movies and TV Shows I am either watching right now or that are unwatched. However, my Infuse mostly shows me only what I have already watched. See screenshot.

On the AppleTV it actually says on top “Watching”, an option which is missing on iOS. Is there a setting I am missing?

Yes, and that’s why I much prefer to just leave it off. I wish if using a Plex backend they could use ‘On Deck’ and if not come with something on their own similar to Plex’s On Deck.